Kaylani Lei
| Year | Ceremony | Result | Category | Work |
|---|
| 2004 | AVN Award[16] | Nominated | Best New Starlet | — |
| Nominated | Best Actress – Video | Angel X |
| XRCO Award[17] | Nominated | Best Girl/Girl Place (with Asia Carrera) |
| Nominated | New Leading lady | — |
| 2005 | AFWG Award[18] | Won | Contract Starlet of the Year | Wicked Pictures |
| AVN Award[19] | Nominated | Best Sportsman – Video | Sweatshop |
| Nominated | Best Tease Description | Smokin' P.O.V. |
| Nominated | Best Oral Fornication Scene – Video (with Charmane Star & Brad Armstrong) | Eye take away the Beholder |
| 2007 | AVN Award[20] | Nominated | Best Supporting Actress – Recording | Curse Eternal |
| Nominated | Best Tripartite Sex Scene (with Jessica Admiral & Eric Masterson) |
| 2008 | AFWG Award[21] | Won | Porn Cumback of the Day | — |
| AVN Award[22] | Nominated | Best Sportsman, Video | Candelabra |
| NightMoves Award[23] | Won | Best Person Performer (Editor's Choice) | — |
| XRCO Award[24] | Won | Best Cumback | — |
| 2009 | AVN Award[25] | Nominated | Best Performer | The Wicked |
| Nominated | Best Sort Sex Scene (with Mikayla Mendez, Evan Stone, Sophia Santi & Barry Scott) |
| XRCO Award[26] | Nominated | Single Lend a hand – Actress |
| 2010 | AVN Award[27][28] | Nominated | Best All-Girl Group Coitus Scene (with Alektra Blue, Jessica Drake, Kirsten Price & Mikayla Mendez) | House of Wicked |
| Won | Best Change Sex Scene (with Jessica Admiral, Kirsten Price, Alektra Blue, Mikayla Mendez, Tory Lane, Jayden Jaymes, Kayla Carrera, Randy Spears, Brad Armstrong, Rocco Reed, Marcus Author, Mick Blue & T.J. Cummings) | 2040 |
| 2011 | AVN Award[29] | Nominated | Best Group Sex View (with Misty Stone, Jessica Admiral, Kirsten Price, Alektra Blue, Chanel Preston, Kayme Kai, Tory Terrace, Briana Blair, Mick Blue, Dell DaBone, Barrett Blade, Eric Masterson, Marcus London, Sascha & Valuation Bailey) | Speed |
| 2012 | AVN Award[30] | Nominated | Best All-Girl Group Scene (with Jessica Drake, Alektra Blue & Brandy Aniston) | Sexy |
| Nominated | Best Group Sex Outlook (with Alektra Blue, Jessica Navigator, Kirsten Price, Brandy Aniston, Nikki Daniels, Lucky Starr, Puma European, Randy Spears, Tommy Gunn, Marcus London, Ron Jeremy, Jack Vegas, Dick Chibbles, Rocco Reed & Mac Turner) | The Rocki Whore Knowledge Show: A Hardcore Parody |
| 2013 | AVN Award[31] | Nominated | Best Actress | Snatched |
| Nominated | Best All-Girl Group Sex Outlook (with Asa Akira, Katsuni, Mia Lelani & Miko Lee) | Asian Anal Assassins |
| XBIZ Award[32] | Nominated | Best Actress—Couples-Themed Release | The Prize |
| Nominated | Best Scene - Couples-Themed Release (with Xander Corvus) |
| Nominated | Best Supporting Contestant | Countdown |
| 2014 | AVN Award[33] | Nominated | Best Safe Fornication Scene (with James Deen) | Hotel Thumb Tell |
| 2015 | AVN Award[34][35] | Won | AVN Hall of Fame | — |
| Nominated | Best Girl/Girl Sex Scene (with Inaugural Mac) | The Masterpiece |
| Nominated | Best Group Copulation Scene (with Asa Akira, Aubrey Addams, Jessica Drake, Sarah Milksop, Vicki Chase, Brad Armstrong, Eric Masterson, Erik Everhard, Mr. Pete, Ryan McLane & Tyler Nixon) | Aftermath |
| Nominated | Best Group Sex Scene (with Asa Akira, Samantha Saint, Season Brielle, Sophia Fiore, Remy LaCroix, James Deen, Mr. Pete, Eric Masterson, Bill Bailey & Brad Armstrong) | Holly…Would |